[CFUD] Cry Wolf 138 - Tiffany

[dreamsofahero]

I have a few questions I wanted to ask, but to start with, I'm curious as to why you voted for Peach instead of Rose in the ousting.

Comments

[dreamsofahero]

Why would a wolf enact such an elaborate plan to try to protect the safe sheep, while still making it known who it is?

[runstowardsfire]

Kara couldn't disappear after the safe sheep clue went up, of course--that's too obvious. But if the wolves realise that the rest of us are talking to her and certain things might slip, they would eat her to stop the flow of information.

[dreamsofahero]

That's assuming both that she knows something about the wolves- which she didn't, incidentally, or didn't that she admitted to me- and that we aren't talking to each other, as well.

[runstowardsfire]

She would have had to be careful. One of us could be a wolf after all.

I found it odd that she wanted to tell her cousin . . .

[dreamsofahero]

Why should that be odd? It's easier to read someone you know well, after all, and she believed he was innocent. If we did get a wolf this time, then she was right.

[runstowardsfire]

Would you tell your friend Ryner about the clue if you were the safe sheep then?

[dreamsofahero]

Of course. Though I could also convince him not to tell anyone even if he weren't also sheep, in any case.

[runstowardsfire]

Ion said they did the private post before the clue.

Why not yesterday? Or after today's round?

[dreamsofahero]

Did which?

[runstowardsfire]

Reveal to her cousin that she was the safe sheep.

[dreamsofahero]

Depending on when she learned of the clue, she may not have had time for it. I didn't have a chance to contact her myself right away, after all.

[runstowardsfire]

I only spoke to her today because I thought she should know and it was already the second round.

We didn't get to speak of anything concrete.

[dreamsofahero]

I asked her about her suspicions, but she said it was too early for her to have anything concrete.

[runstowardsfire]

Maybe she was being cautious . . . then again it might have been too early in the game.

[dreamsofahero]

No, I don't imagine why she'd have any reason to be cautious, especially since I already knew she was the safe sheep- even if I were a wolf, she'd be in no more danger than she was to begin with, and I would have had to risk looking suspicious if I'd asked her opinion and then argued with her. So no, it's unlikely she was withholding anything, at least not deliberately.

[runstowardsfire]

Something might have only started looking suspicious after the second round . . .

[dreamsofahero]

Exactly.

Even so, I think the most logical approach would be to assume that all of us who knew about the safe sheep are sheep, and that Scarlett was the wolf. It gives us the most narrow area within which to begin looking at things.

[runstowardsfire]

If Scarlett was the wolf, then Gray and Azure are sheep.

If you count Ion, myself and you as sheep, then we are left with Peach, Plum and White as potential wolves.

[dreamsofahero]

*nods*

I've been speaking with Sano from the start, and while I can't completely rule him out, if he is a wolf he's gone to unusual lengths to try to hide it. The other two I've yet to speak much with, however.

[runstowardsfire]

And Xia Tian has two personalities.

[dreamsofahero]

That does complicate things quite a bit, yes.

[runstowardsfire]

Which one to trust . . . but we might not see the other one again, so we have to focus on Xia Tian.

[dreamsofahero]

Well, it turns out he's one of the ones named in the clue, it seems.